Hi Gilly,
Welcome to the site, if this is to be your first visit to Arillas then I'm sure you will not be disappointed and if this is a return visit then you already know what a great place it is
I can only vouch for the Mathraki as I have not stayed in any of the other apts on your list. We have stayed in the Mathraki many, many times.
The location is very good if you want to be near the beach, shops, tavernas etc. Paul I've got to disagree with you regarding the Mathraki being half-way up the 'slight' hill up to Christos
, methinks that Philip's Ouzo has clouded your judgement
...the Mathraki is only a short walk up the hill!
You can walk to the beach from the Mathraki by taking the road past the shops etc, or go down via the pretty little country lane which ends up at a traditional taverna looking over the beach. This is a quiet little taverna, a good chilling out place after a strenous few hours on the beach! Take your book up and have a snack and a drink and your will be so relaxed you will stay longer than you intended!!
Nicolette and her family will make you feel very welcome in their own quiet way. They provide reasonably priced light meals and snacks at their
poolside bar, everyone must try Nicolettes Greek Ommlette made with eggs from her own hens running aroung the back garden! Very yummy lunchtime snack washed down with local wine or retsina.
We arrive on the 24th June so we might see you there.
Eileen.x