Hi, we felt the same after reading reviews about arillas. It was our first time to Corfu last September, we went to Ag. Gordios and would have liked to go back but couldnt get the same accommodation. The best option we came up with was Arillas. We are staying in the Galini Hotel/studios in June. Try
www.galini-hotels.com and booked through Thomas Cook and it was very good, there is a link through the forum on this site.. The offer at the time was £290 for two weeks each person, which we thought was brilliant!
The weather last September in Ag. Gordios (south -west side) was very good. Hot, but not unbearable. Bit overcast a couple of days and windy, even started raining one afternoon, but it made a nice change. The last day it 'tipped' it down then 1hr later out came the sun... A cardi or wrap was welcome in the evenings though. We are looking forward to visiting Arillas very much. Hope you manage to find something too.